Can Family Socioeconomic Resources Account for Racial and Ethnic Test Score Gaps?
Duncan, Greg J.; Magnuson, Katherine A. Future of Children, v15 n1 p35-54 Spr 2005
Abstract:
This article considers whether the disparate socioeconomic circumstances
of families in which white, black, and Hispanic children grow up
account for the racial and ethnic gaps in school readiness among
American preschoolers. It first reviews why family socioeconomic
resources might matter for children's school readiness. The authors
concentrate on four key components of parent socioeconomic status that
are particularly relevant for children's well-being--income, education,
family structure, and neighborhood conditions. They survey a range of
relevant policies and programs that might help to close socioeconomic
gaps, for example, by increasing family incomes or maternal educational
attainment, strengthening families, and improving poor neighborhoods.
Their survey of links between socioeconomic resources and test score
gaps indicates that resource differences account for about half of the
standard deviation--about 8 points on a test with a standard deviation
of 15--of the differences. Yet, the policy implications of this are far
from clear. They note that although policies are designed to improve
aspects of "socioeconomic status" (for example, income, education,
family structure), no policy improves "socioeconomic status" directly.
Second, they caution that good policy is based on an understanding of
causal relationships between family background and children outcomes, as
well as cost-effectiveness. They conclude that boosting the family
incomes of preschool children may be a promising intervention to reduce
racial and ethnic school readiness gaps. However, given the lack of
successful large-scale interventions, the authors suggest giving only a
modest role to programs that address parents' socioeconomic resources.
They suggest that policies that directly target children may be the most
efficient way to narrow school readiness gaps.
FOC journal - 15_01_03.pdf
http://eric.ed.gov/?id=EJ795842
Saturday, March 14, 2015
Monday, February 16, 2015
Another View
Neither Broad Nor Bold - Education Next : Education Next
Paul Peterson
Education Next
Children raised in families with higher incomes score higher on math and
reading tests. That is no less true in the Age of Obama than it was in
the Age of Pericles or, for that matter, in the Age of Mao. But is
parental income the cause of a child’s success? Or is the
connection between income and achievement largely a symptom of something
else: genetic heritage, parental skill, or a supportive educational
setting?
Paul Peterson
Education Next
SUMMER 2012 / VOL. 12, NO. 3
Intro: Children raised in families with higher incomes score higher on math and
reading tests. That is no less true in the Age of Obama than it was in
the Age of Pericles or, for that matter, in the Age of Mao. But is
parental income the cause of a child’s success? Or is the
connection between income and achievement largely a symptom of something
else: genetic heritage, parental skill, or a supportive educational
setting?
ERIC - The Economics of Inequality: The Value of Early Childhood Education, American Educator, 2011
ERIC - The Economics of Inequality: The Value of Early Childhood Education, American Educator, 2011
Educational
equity is often discussed as a moral issue. Another way to think about
equity is as a way to promote productivity and economic efficiency.
Traditionally, equity and efficiency are viewed as competing goals. One
can be fair in devising a policy, but it often happens that what is fair
is not economically efficient. Conversely, what is efficient may not be
fair. What is remarkable is that there are some policies that both are
fair--i.e., promote equity--and promote economic efficiency. Investing
in the early years of disadvantaged children's lives is one such policy.
A large body of data from economics, biology, and psychology shows that
educational equity is more than a social justice imperative; it is an
economic imperative that has far-reaching implications for the nation.
Taking a hard look at the economic value of efforts to create human
capital helps people see where best to invest their resources in
education to achieve its ideal--equalizing opportunity to build greater
and enduring value for all. The evidence is quite clear that inequality
in the development of human capabilities produces negative social and
economic outcomes that can and should be prevented with investments in
early childhood education, particularly targeted toward disadvantaged
children and their families.
American Educator, v35 n1 p31-35, 47 Spr 2011
Abstract Educational
equity is often discussed as a moral issue. Another way to think about
equity is as a way to promote productivity and economic efficiency.
Traditionally, equity and efficiency are viewed as competing goals. One
can be fair in devising a policy, but it often happens that what is fair
is not economically efficient. Conversely, what is efficient may not be
fair. What is remarkable is that there are some policies that both are
fair--i.e., promote equity--and promote economic efficiency. Investing
in the early years of disadvantaged children's lives is one such policy.
A large body of data from economics, biology, and psychology shows that
educational equity is more than a social justice imperative; it is an
economic imperative that has far-reaching implications for the nation.
Taking a hard look at the economic value of efforts to create human
capital helps people see where best to invest their resources in
education to achieve its ideal--equalizing opportunity to build greater
and enduring value for all. The evidence is quite clear that inequality
in the development of human capabilities produces negative social and
economic outcomes that can and should be prevented with investments in
early childhood education, particularly targeted toward disadvantaged
children and their families.
ERIC - Parsing the Achievement Gap II. Policy Information Report, Educational Testing Service, 2009-Apr
ERIC - Parsing the Achievement Gap II. Policy Information Report, Educational Testing Service, 2009-Apr
Gaps
in school achievement among racial/ethnic groups and between students
from different socioeconomic circumstances are well documented. They are
wide and persistent, well known and widely acknowledged. This report
focuses on the conditions and experiences that create and perpetuate
achievement gaps. It is the second edition of the report "Parsing the
Achievement Gap: Baselines for Tracking Progress," published in 2003.
The report focuses on the many antecedents of differences in school
achievement. The review begins by identifying school and home conditions
that the research community largely agrees are associated with school
achievement, although there are points of disagreement. Research is a
continuing process of thesis and antithesis, and what seems to be
established may be challenged. This new report adds another dimension to
the original report by assessing whether there have been changes in
these critical factors since then, and judges whether any progress has
been made in closing the gaps in these correlates of achievement. The
report concludes that minority students and poor students continue to
face conditions that undermine school achievement. The authors advocate
that policies and practices that are likely to narrow gaps in
achievement need to be broad and comprehensive to check inequality at
the outset of a child's academic career and create conditions in which
every child can flourish, achieve, and attain in school and in life.
Barton, Paul E.; Coley, Richard J.
Educational Testing Service
Abstract
in school achievement among racial/ethnic groups and between students
from different socioeconomic circumstances are well documented. They are
wide and persistent, well known and widely acknowledged. This report
focuses on the conditions and experiences that create and perpetuate
achievement gaps. It is the second edition of the report "Parsing the
Achievement Gap: Baselines for Tracking Progress," published in 2003.
The report focuses on the many antecedents of differences in school
achievement. The review begins by identifying school and home conditions
that the research community largely agrees are associated with school
achievement, although there are points of disagreement. Research is a
continuing process of thesis and antithesis, and what seems to be
established may be challenged. This new report adds another dimension to
the original report by assessing whether there have been changes in
these critical factors since then, and judges whether any progress has
been made in closing the gaps in these correlates of achievement. The
report concludes that minority students and poor students continue to
face conditions that undermine school achievement. The authors advocate
that policies and practices that are likely to narrow gaps in
achievement need to be broad and comprehensive to check inequality at
the outset of a child's academic career and create conditions in which
every child can flourish, achieve, and attain in school and in life.
ERIC - The Black-White Achievement Gap: When Progress Stopped. Policy Information Report, Educational Testing Service, 2010-Jul
ERIC - The Black-White Achievement Gap: When Progress Stopped. Policy Information Report, Educational Testing Service, 2010-Jul
This
report is about understanding the periods of progress and the periods
of stagnation in changes in the achievement gap that have occurred over
the past several decades. The authors try to understand what might have
contributed to the progress as well as probe the reasons that may
account for the progress halting, in the hope of finding some clues and
possible directions for moving forward in narrowing the achievement gap.
The authors focus on three periods of history, but not in chronological
order. The first is the decades of the 1970s and 1980s, when NAEP
(National Assessment of Educational Progress) reported large reductions
in the gaps in reading and mathematics scores. Second, the report focus
on the period from about 1990 until 2008, when the gap wobbled around a
generally straight trend line, although scores of 9- and 13-year-olds
generally rose overall. And third, the report takes a more expansive
view, beginning early in the 20th century, in an attempt to understand
the impact of a variety of factors on changes in the gap. These factors
include information on educational attainment, employment and earnings,
child well-being, the family, neighborhoods and the effects of
concentrated poverty and deprivation, lack of social capital, and
intergenerational mobility. Appendices include: (1) Trends in NAEP
White-Black Reading Gaps at Selected Percentiles; and (2) Trends in NAEP
White-Black Mathematics Gaps at Selected Percentiles.
The Black-White Achievement Gap: When Progress Stopped. Policy Information Report
Barton, Paul E.; Coley, Richard J.
Educational Testing Service
report is about understanding the periods of progress and the periods
of stagnation in changes in the achievement gap that have occurred over
the past several decades. The authors try to understand what might have
contributed to the progress as well as probe the reasons that may
account for the progress halting, in the hope of finding some clues and
possible directions for moving forward in narrowing the achievement gap.
The authors focus on three periods of history, but not in chronological
order. The first is the decades of the 1970s and 1980s, when NAEP
(National Assessment of Educational Progress) reported large reductions
in the gaps in reading and mathematics scores. Second, the report focus
on the period from about 1990 until 2008, when the gap wobbled around a
generally straight trend line, although scores of 9- and 13-year-olds
generally rose overall. And third, the report takes a more expansive
view, beginning early in the 20th century, in an attempt to understand
the impact of a variety of factors on changes in the gap. These factors
include information on educational attainment, employment and earnings,
child well-being, the family, neighborhoods and the effects of
concentrated poverty and deprivation, lack of social capital, and
intergenerational mobility. Appendices include: (1) Trends in NAEP
White-Black Reading Gaps at Selected Percentiles; and (2) Trends in NAEP
White-Black Mathematics Gaps at Selected Percentiles.
ERIC - The Family: America's Smallest School. Policy Information Report, Educational Testing Service, 2007-Sep
ERIC - The Family: America's Smallest School. Policy Information Report, Educational Testing Service, 2007-Sep
Barton, Paul E.; Coley, Richard J.Abstract
The
family and the home are both critical education institutions where
children begin learning before they start school, and where they spend
much of their time after they start school. It therefore follows that
improving a child's home environment to make it more conducive to
learning is critical to improving the educational achievement of the
nation's students and closing achievement gaps. The kinds of family and
home conditions that research has found to make a difference in
children's cognitive development and school achievement include: (1)
Parent-Pupil Ratio; (2) Family Finances; (3) Literacy Development; (4)
Child Care Disparities; (5) Home as an Educational Resource; and (6)
Parent-School Relationship. The authors discuss how family and home
characteristics can be used to predict student achievement, and what
current family trends imply about the future state of student learning
in the United States. Statistics and research findings are included from
small research studies, national censuses and databases, and
international surveys. Information is targeted to readers with different
interests, perspectives and needs, but with a common interest in
improving student learning and reducing achievement gaps. A table of
predicted achievement in 8th grade reading by state is appended.
Barton, Paul E.; Coley, Richard J.
Educational Testing Service
The
family and the home are both critical education institutions where
children begin learning before they start school, and where they spend
much of their time after they start school. It therefore follows that
improving a child's home environment to make it more conducive to
learning is critical to improving the educational achievement of the
nation's students and closing achievement gaps. The kinds of family and
home conditions that research has found to make a difference in
children's cognitive development and school achievement include: (1)
Parent-Pupil Ratio; (2) Family Finances; (3) Literacy Development; (4)
Child Care Disparities; (5) Home as an Educational Resource; and (6)
Parent-School Relationship. The authors discuss how family and home
characteristics can be used to predict student achievement, and what
current family trends imply about the future state of student learning
in the United States. Statistics and research findings are included from
small research studies, national censuses and databases, and
international surveys. Information is targeted to readers with different
interests, perspectives and needs, but with a common interest in
improving student learning and reducing achievement gaps. A table of
predicted achievement in 8th grade reading by state is appended.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)